Aliyar Iqubal vs Hon. Attorney-General – CA 07/2010-2014

In the case between Aliyar Iqubal (Accused-Appellant) and the Hon. Attorney-General (Respondent), the court examined whether the conviction and sentence imposed by the High Court of Trincomalee for murder were lawful and supported by adequate evidence. It was held that the trial court’s process and evaluation of evidence were deficient and that the evidence did not establish the prosecution’s case beyond reasonable doubt. The decision underscored that criminal convictions must be supported by reliable evidence and rigorous judicial assessment, referencing important procedural integrity and evidentiary standards. The conviction and sentence were accordingly set aside, and the appeal was allowed, reinforcing the requirement for strict adherence to evidentiary standards in criminal trials.

A